Keeping Your Artwork Clean Part 2. Watercolour: Avoiding Mistakes and Fixing Them
Updated: Oct 27
Watercolour can feel quite unforgiving when you're learning, but many common problems can either be prevented or improved through careful observation and technique. We're often told that the best approach is simply to avoid mistakes altogether, but the reality is that accidents will happen. Not every mistake can be repaired, yet these 'mistakes' can be some of the most valuable learning opportunities. Understanding what went wrong, why it happened, and how it might be avoided next time is all part of the watercolour journey.
There are numerous things that can go wrong when working with watercolour and, in this post, I'll address some of the most common issues. Images and videos will be added at a later - to help illustrate the points discussed. Much of the information here relates to working with wet washes and wet layers. I will cover common dry-brush problems and solutions in a separate post.
One of the most useful skills to develop is learning how to recognise mistakes early and knowing how to correct them. But first, here are a few tips on avoiding mistakes:
Preventing Mistakes
Keep the Workspace Organised
A surprising amount of paint splats can occur because of the workplace arrangement and failing to protect your work
Use two water pots, one for the washing of the brush and the other for the painting. Otherwise, you are painting with dirty water!
Make sure your paints, palette and water containers are positioned on the same side as your painting hand. It is surprising how many students I see at workshops with their water pot on one side and their palette on the other, repeatedly trailing a wet brush across their work, which often results in unwanted drips, paint splashes or accidental marks on the painting.
Protect the artwork with tracing paper, cut a hole for the area that you are working on
Spend More Time Observing
Many problems with watercolour begin before the brush touches the paper. Take time and don't rush in because - making adequate observations before you begin painting limits the need to move or lift paint, which is never a good idea. Observe:
The direction of light - so that you don't paint over the highlights or pale areas
Observe subtle colour shifts
If you don't make adequate observations before you begin painting you can end up trying to move or lift paint, which can end up with overworked paper. You can lift when wet but need to be cautious as some colours dont easily lift and stain the paper.
Work Light to Dark
Watercolour requires preservation the white of the paper and transparency. Begin with the pale layers and gradually build depth using a range of techniques. You can create form and maintain light from the start. I seldom use all over washes and instead build the form by dampening and adding colour only where needed, this way you maintain highlights or can add pale form shadows first - simple by painting into a surface dampened with clean water.


Common mistakes:
Applying tea washes all over the foundation layer - loses the highlights
Applying dark or heavy colour too soon.
Failing to allow each wash to dry before adding the next (unless deliberately painting into damp)
Test Colour First and Paint Swatches
Always test mixtures on a scrap of paper before applying them to your painting. Colours often dry lighter than expected and may behave differently than they appear in the palette. Paint swatches from saturated to a pale tint. Keep a scribble sheet of watercolour paper next to your painting. Most artist have sheets like this next to their painting

Use The Right Amount of Water
Possibly the most difficult area of mastering watercolour and something that comes with practice - you will get a 'feel' for water and paint ratios with practice and ratios will vary depending on the subject, the colour and required outcome. Practice really does make perfect - so do try to paint often, small subjects are good practice.
Many beginners use paint that is either too thick or conversely are always dipping into the water pot and making dilute puddles that can result weak uncontrolled colour and ragged edges
Different colours also vary in saturation, so the dilution required varies too. That's why its important to understand all of the colours in your palette, and therir properties, such as staining power, saturation and granulation.
Use the Appropriate Brush for the Job
The brush must be the right size for the task, washes require a larger brush and detail a smaller one. Which size of brush depends on the size of the subject. I mostly use sizes 1/2 W & N Series 7 miniatures and 4/5 brushes for larger areas.


Common Problems and How to Fix Them
Hard or Ragged Outer Edges
Cause:
Working back into the areas before the wash has dried and pushing the paint to the edge
Too much water was added, resulting in the pigment separating from the water and migrating to the outer edge (pigment particles are heavier than the water particles). This causes the classic ragged edge.
Fix:
Dampen the brush and gently soften the edge with the brush working inwards from the edge.
A small flat or filbert brush can be useful on larger areas.
Do not wet too much and never scrub
Patchy Washes
Cause:
Working into a drying wash is the most common cause
Insufficient paint mixture prepared, so paint is drying before more is added
Using a brush that's too small, results in small strokes with a brush that doesn't hold enough paint
Avoid /Fix:
Mix larger quantities before starting.
Apply washes confidently (don't' hesitate too much).
Allow washes to dry undisturbed.
Don't use a brush that's too small because it doesn't hold enough paint in its belly
Blooming or Cauliflowers
Cause:
Adding wet paint into a partially drying wash
being impatient and adding more when only the surface is dry but the paper is wet beneath.
Training a wet brush over your work and dropping water onto painted areas
Avoid/Fix:
Wait until fully dry before repainting.
Alternatively, dampen the entire area and blot with paper. Smooth with a soft damp brush
keep the water pot on the correct side to avoid water drops
Moving or Lifting Colour Accidentally
Cause:
Colour lifted unintentionally leaving pale patches by using a brush that's too wet or by working on an area that's isn't fully dry
Avoid/Fix:
Allow the paint to dry completely.
Dampen and gently blot with paper or a clean brush.
Repeat application of paint.
For small areas -retouch using dry brush with tiny lightweight strokes and a small brush, size 1 or 2 miniature or similar. (You must be proficient with dry brush technique to do this)
Colours Look Muddy or Dull
Cause:
Too many layers, leading to over saturation of colour
Excessive mixing of colours - too many pigments lead to grey and brown and dirty colours.
Reworking into damp paint repeatedly and damaging the surface of the paper (impatient painters)
Using too much water - causes many problems/ Heavily diluted paint is less bright and the dilute paint will sink deep into the paper - causing a flat dull appearance. This paint can never be lifted because it's too deep.
Avoid/ Fix:
Use a limited palette and know how your colours behave instead of having a multitude of colours that you don't even know the name of. Practice colour mixing beforehand.
Stop and allow the painting to dry completely.
Glaze with cleaner, more transparent colour.
In severe cases, carefully lift colour slowly, this may take several attempts, blot each time and allow to fully dry - then repaint when dry (the last resort, may not work if colour is staining or paper is damaged)
Painting Looks Flat/ Lack of Shadow or Lost Highlights
Cause:
Insufficient tonal contrast
lack of good lighting on the subject
Not enough attention to light and shadow - don't forget the value of cast shadows too
Painting over the highlights
Avoid/Fix:
Compare your darkest values with the subject.
Strengthen shadows gradually.
Remember that colour alone cannot create form; tonal variation is essential.
Readdress the lighting on your subject.
Avoid painting over highlights by dampening rather than wetting the area, which allows better control of the paint so that it doesn't flow into the highlight
If dealing with a lost highlight - consider whether there is room to make the surrounding area tonally darker- which may enhance the appearance of the highlight. Often the highlight isn't completely lost - and more work on the surrounding area restores a highlight.
If the highlight is painted over and paint is still fully wet - quickly lift the colour while wet with a clean brush
Otherwise when fully dry - take a short haired brush, such as an eradicator or small flat synthetic brush (size 0 or 1). Dampen the area with clean water and leave for a few seconds - then with the clean damp flat brush, attempt to lift the paint - do not scrub! blot with tissue and allow to dry- repeat if necessary when dry to lift more paint. Do not be impatient - repeat in stages or the paper will be damaged. Success will depend on the staining quality ofg the paint and also the paper.
Lifting fluids are available but in my experience, they are of limited value and can cause other problems e.g. Schmincke Aqua Lift-Off Medium, Winsor & Newton Lifting Preparation or Daniel Smith Lift Aid, which are applied before painting.

Damaged Overworked Paper
Causes:
There can be many causes but typically:
Lifting paint - can disturb the paper sizing. Some papers are more robust than others.
Scrubbing the paper to move paint - damages the surface
Too much water - raises the paper surface and degrades the external sizing of the paper.
Fix:
Allow to dry completely and naturally (and never use a hairdryer to dry you paper, it will dry the surface unevenly)
Use a smooth stone, such as Agate, a burnishing tool or even the back of a spoon to flatten the raised paper fibres, this won't restore the sizing but will smooth the paper enough to work on again.
Many watercolours are harmed by overworking rather than underworking, so you need to learn when to stop. Step away for an hour or two or even overnight. Fresh eyes often reveal whether the painting truly needs more work.
Removing Accidental Paint Splashes on the White of the Paper
I already covered how to avoid these at the start of this article. Fixing them can depend on several factors, such as the size of the paint splash, saturation of colour, whether the paint has penetrated the surface layer etc.
To Fix:
Small dry splatters that sit on the surface - I generally lift these off with a sharp scalpel, a shallow cut will easily remove them.
Light larger splashes - wash out with clean water and an eradicator brush, blotting each time and allow to dry completely and lift in stages.
Once paper is completely dry - burnish the surface it to smooth it completely
there other options but they are more complex depending on the repair required but these are more complex.

Keep in Mind:
Finally, rather than thinking of mistakes as failures, think of them as part of your learning process. If you are currenty undertaking the Watercolour Techniques assignment - don't expect the exercises to be perfect - they won't be. So, errors such as ragged or hard edges, overworked paper, muddy colour all teaches you something about water control, timing and paint handling.
Even experienced botanical artists continually make corrections throughout a painting, the main difference is that they recognise problems early and address them.
The Leaf and Flower Portraits and the Study Pages exercises will provide an excellent opportunity for you to refine your techniques and to understand how to minimise and repair.
In botanical watercolour, patience is often the best correction tool of all. A carefully observed subject, a sound drawing, and slow, deliberate layering will prevent most problems before they occur





Thank you Dianne for this collection. I still do many mistakes which you addressed.👍